So I go to their web site, and after entering my zip code, the site asks the question:
"Would you like to use your A-list membership in other states?"
I'm in NYC with no car, so I pick "NO". Believing that I would be offered the a lower membership price since I won't be using it in any other states. I got the $23.95 + tax. Not bad.
Then, out of curiosity I wanted to see how much was the other membership, you know, the one across states lines, and lo and behold... well, I was offered the most expensive membership since I was not going to use it outside my state.
Dark Patterns at work!
See for yourself at https://imgur.com/a/aCkidgl.
Maybe not illegal but, enough to turn me off, I didn't complete the purchase and I have an aversion for AMC now.